I made a Kalshi account, put in $10, and then did absolutely nothing with it.
No bets. No predictions. Just a guy with ten dollars and a browser tab, wandering around a prediction market like it’s a museum and I’m not allowed to touch the exhibits. (I might bet eventually. I might also let the $10 sit there forever as a very expensive screensaver. Undecided.)
I wasn’t there to make money. I was there out of curiosity, which is the only reason I do half the things I do.
But scrolling through all of it, every question with a percentage slapped next to it, something in my brain started turning in a different direction. I got meta curious. Not “what’s going to happen?” but “what does it mean when a lot of people think something is going to happen?”
🧠 The Question
So I did what any reasonable person does with a half-formed thought at an unreasonable hour: I took it to an AI. I opened Gemini and typed out something like this:
Is there a predictive outcome percentage increase based on public perception? Regardless of whether anyone contributes to the outcome, can the sheer quantity of people’s predictions affect the likelihood of it happening? Like, if 92% of Americans believe a certain thing will happen in America, does that have a good likelihood of becoming true?
(Yes, that’s the cleaned-up version. The original had more typos and less punctuation. Moving on.)
The short answer: sometimes, and it depends entirely on why they believe it. Which is a very “it depends” answer, but it turns out the “it depends” is the whole point. It split into three outcomes.
🎯 Outcome 1: The Crowd Is Just Right
This is the wisdom-of-crowds one. A big, diverse group of people each know a tiny piece of something. Nobody has the full picture, but everybody has a scrap. Put thousands of scraps together and the individual mistakes cancel out, leaving a signal that’s often better than what a single expert could produce.
That’s the whole engine behind prediction markets like Kalshi and Polymarket. Which, okay, explains why I was staring at those percentages like they were weather forecasts for the future.
The catch is independence. Everyone has to be arriving at their guess on their own, from their own little corner of the world. Hold that thought, because it comes back to bite us in Outcome 3.
🔄 Outcome 2: The Belief Makes It Happen
This is the one that broke my brain a little. It’s called reflexivity.
The idea: it doesn’t matter if the belief started out right or wrong. If enough people believe something will happen, they start acting like it’s going to happen, and their behavior is what makes it happen. The prediction isn’t observing reality anymore. It’s steering it.
The classic example is a bank run. Say 92% of people become convinced a perfectly healthy bank is about to collapse. They all rush to pull their money out today. And now the bank collapses. Not because it was ever going to, but because everyone believed it would. The prediction wrote its own ending.
Elections work a little like this too. If everybody thinks a candidate is a sure thing, you get momentum, donations, and turnout, and the sure thing gets a lot surer.
But the best example, the one that proves it, is one we all lived through:
The Great Toilet Paper Crisis of Covid.
Remember that? Everybody heard some vague thing about China and decided we were about to run out of toilet paper, so they stocked up. Let’s break down this legendary self-fulfilling prophecy.
The panic. A possible toilet paper shortage, based on a belief with basically nothing behind it. (Quick, without Googling: can you remember why people thought it was going to happen? Me neither.)
The rush. Nobody wants a dirty booty, so everyone bolts to their local Walmart. And they don’t grab a reasonable amount. They grab tens of packs, if not more.
The domino. Now a ton of people are leaving with a shit-ton of toilet paper, which makes the people who had no clue panic too. They also don’t want a dirty booty, so they grab what they can and stock up.
The shortage. The sheer rate of anti-dirty-booty demand outran the supply of booty cleaners, and we got an actual toilet paper shortage. We became the architects of our own booty-cleaning rapture.
I know it’s silly, but think about what really happened. A belief with no foundation altered reality. Nobody lied, nobody sabotaged anything, we just all agreed on a future and then built it. A delicious ouroboros, tail firmly in mouth.
Sit with that for a second. The forecast isn’t a spectator. It’s a player. (I told you my brain turned. This is the part where it turned the hardest.)
🪞 Outcome 3: Everybody Is Wrong Together
Here’s the plot twist. A huge percentage of people can believe something and be completely wrong, if they all got the idea from the same place.
Remember how Outcome 1 needed independence? This is what happens without it. If 92% believe something because they all saw the same headline, the same algorithm, or the same group chat, that’s not 92 independent guesses. That’s one guess, photocopied a lot of times.
The history is full of this. Everybody was sure housing could only go up, until 2007. Everybody was sure tech stocks could only go up, until 2000. And for centuries, basically everyone was certain the sun orbited the Earth. Belief doesn’t change physics. It just makes the mistake bigger.
⚖️ So Where Does That Leave Me?
The way I’ve boiled it down, and I want to be clear I’m a guy with $10 and a Gemini tab, not an economist:
🧩 If the crowd got there independently, from different sources and different angles, a high percentage is a really strong signal.
📢 If the crowd got there through the same source, the percentage doesn’t tell you what’s going to happen. It tells you how powerful the story is.
🔁 And sometimes it’s both, because the story can be strong enough to make itself come true.
Which leaves me with an annoying little puzzle: when I look at a number on Kalshi, am I looking at a prediction, or am I looking at a cause? And can anyone actually tell the difference from the outside?
I don’t have an answer. I have ten dollars and a tab I keep reopening.
So here’s my question for you, genuinely: think of something you’re sure is going to happen. Now ask yourself where you got that certainty. Did you work it out yourself, or did you absorb it? I’m not judging. I’m asking because I’m now doing this to myself on every topic, and I’d like some company.

